Do not buy a GPU to avoid a policy decision
Start with a hosted API when its terms and technical behaviour meet the requirement and the team does not need to operate inference. Consider self-hosting when a concrete infrastructure constraint justifies the work and a responsible team can sustain it.
The choice is not simply privacy versus convenience. A self-hosted system can still expose data through logs, integrations or an insecure endpoint. A hosted service can offer contractual controls that need careful verification. Deployment location is part of the decision, not a complete data policy.
Write the actual requirement first: permitted processing locations, allowed external transfers, retention expectations, model capabilities and recovery needs. A vague preference for control cannot be tested.
Separate training, retention and access
Whether a provider uses inputs for training is different from whether it stores requests, who can access them and which product terms apply. Do not carry assurances from a consumer subscription into a commercial API without checking.
Anthropic states that its commercial offerings do not use customer chats or coding sessions for model training by default, with exceptions for explicit participation or feedback described in its policy. That statement does not itself establish zero retention or suitability for every dataset. Anthropic commercial data policy
For either approach, map the complete data path, including observability and support tools. Have the responsible privacy and security owners assess the actual configuration and agreements. Architecture cannot substitute for that review.
Compare accepted work, not the model label
Evaluate candidate models on the same representative tasks, output constraints and refusal cases. A model that runs in the desired environment is not automatically capable enough for the product.
Measure completion quality, response time under realistic concurrency and the work required to correct failures. A cheap answer that repeatedly needs human repair may be an expensive business result. Our cost per completed AI task guide makes that accounting explicit.
Keep model choice separate from serving choice where possible. Changing both simultaneously makes it difficult to know whether an improvement came from the model, the deployment or a changed prompt.
Self-hosting creates an operating product
An owned inference service needs capacity planning, monitoring, updates, access control and a failure path. The team must understand queuing and what happens when demand exceeds available capacity.
For example, vLLM exposes production metrics including queue time and time to first token. These are useful operational signals, not proof that a particular deployment will meet a latency target. vLLM production metrics
Include idle capacity, redundancy, model loading, evaluation and engineering time in the comparison. Avoid a universal break-even request count: workload shape and hardware utilisation change the economics.
A hosted API also needs timeouts, usage controls and a service-failure response. Moving inference outside the team removes some operating work, not the responsibility for the user experience.
Build the decision record this week
Choose a representative workload and write its acceptance criteria before testing. Run a small comparison with the same inputs and record accepted outcomes, waiting time, failure handling and operational tasks.
Ask who will respond when the self-hosted service stops, or when the API becomes unavailable. Document an exit path and a model replacement test. Do not promise automatic fallback if a replacement has not passed the same checks.
Clodron's AI automation engineering can work with either approach. Prefer the deployment whose controls and operating burden fit the product, not the one that turns infrastructure ownership into a badge.
